Site menu:

Site search

Get Updates

Enter your email address to hear about new posts. (You can view my privacy policy here.)


RSS Recent Posts

Archives (month)


Banking on it

A friend writes to tell me that she has been appointed to the Future of Banking Commission set up by Which?. Which reminds me that I have yet to return to my September Blog on the subject of regulation, in particular the regulation of banks.

I don’t subscribe to the “too big to fail” approach. I don’t believe it is about size. Who, prior to 2007, would have thought that Northern Rock was “too big” in any meaningful sense of the phrase?

I look at this from the perspective of someone who first learned about regulation in the context of the utilities. Banks provide us with somewhere to place our funds, particularly any funds that exceed our immediate needs, so that the money can be loaned out to those whose immediate needs exceed their current funds.

There is no reason why all the depositors should ever need their money back simultaneously. We just need to ensure that they don’t all suddenly want their money back simultaneously. For this to happen, the depositors need confidence that the bank will be there – and be solvent – when their funds are required. Anything which jeopardises that confidence jeopardises the deposit-and-lend part of the banking system. It is these banks (regardless of their size) which need to be ring-fenced from harm – together with any part of the financial system which underpins them, for example, any related credit insurance operations.

There are those who say that splitting banks between “the part that needs protecting” and “the rest” is too complex to achieve at this point. I can accept that we may not, now, be starting from the ideal place. But, somehow or other, we need to create a position in which the banking function which exists in order for the financial system to operate is isolated from those operations which are capable of destroying the system. If that isn’t possible (and some say it isn’t), it would seem to follow that deposit-and-lend banking is implicitly a self-destructive system. I don’t believe that is true.

See also:  Bankers cooking with Gas?

Sign up for updates by Email, Twitter or RSS Feed.

Related articles on this website
Regular readers of this blog must be sick to death by now of me repeating how much damage accounting standards are doing to pension schemes (here, here, here and, even ...
Read the complete article
I think the three words at the end of the following sentence must be the most chilling – and the most heart-warming – I have ever read from an accounting ...
Read the complete article
I see the Treasury has been consulting on its new approach to financial regulation. Some of the main ideas – reforming the tri-partite model – have been discussed at length ...
Read the complete article
The separation of retail and investment banks is back in the news following the Chancellor’s recent Mansion House speech. Ever since the Government bail-out of Royal Bank of Scotland and ...
Read the complete article
Until a few days ago, I had never heard the expression: "When you hear hoofbeats, think of horses not zebras". A visiting US professor used it in conversation with me. ...
Read the complete article
I took the morning off to watch Andy Murray’s semi-final in Australia before heading to the Centre for the Study of Financial Innovation for a discussion on risk modelling. Intriguingly, ...
Read the complete article
Lindsay Tomlinson is calling for a summit to change the way pension costs are calculated in company accounts. As chairman of the National Association of Pension Funds, Tomlinson would say ...
Read the complete article
… to be giving a presentation whilst the audience is tweeting their comments onto a screen behind your head. Perhaps that’s going to be the way of the future. For me, ...
Read the complete article
Accountants in a tangle with Webb
Accountants becoming effective?
Probably the best regulator in the world?
Bankers cooking with Gas?
A horse. A zebra. Or maybe it’s a fish?
Game, Stress & Match
Time to start thinking again, I think
It’s very disconcerting …